Why Inventing Color TV Was So Difficult [video] (youtube.com)

by DamnInteresting 12 comments 42 points
Read article View on HN

12 comments

[−] grishka 41d ago
I grew quite an appreciation of color TV recently when I made a software-defined SECAM decoder. It's mind-boggling that they were able to do this with 60s technology, to be honest. But then what do I know, analog electronics is witchcraft to me :D

https://github.com/grishka/miscellaneous/blob/master/AVDecod...

edit: I watched the video. It only took them until the 13th minute of a 15-minute video to show something resembling a real video waveform, lol. That's, uh, not how you explain how TV works.

[−] pavlov 41d ago
SECAM was pretty crazy because it required a delay line: a memory that would hold the previous scanline so it can be combined with the current one.

Without digital circuits, the delay line was a piece of glass. You’d convert the video signal to a sound wave, send it through the glass, and (hopefully) get it back exactly 64 us later so it aligns with the next scanline.

Here’s a picture: https://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/glass-ultrasonic-dela...

[−] mpalmer 41d ago
In the first 90 seconds, the narration refers to "the insane 19th century electronics that made color possible", but is referring to the 1900s, which were the 20th century.

The video contains no insight at all into "why" color TV was so difficult. It just lists and describes a few key advancements.

Also the "invention" of color TV is very different from the commercialization.

[−] AlexDragusin 41d ago
Alec Watson from Technology Connections did an entire series on this subject:

(How Analog Color TV Works: The Beginnings) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dX649lnKAU0

Then the playlist on TV stuff: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l4UgZBs7ZGo&list=PLv0jwu7G_D...

Don't blame me for the rabbit hole :P

[−] pavlov 41d ago
Tintin readers will remember the pains suffered by viewers of early color TV experiments (“The Castafiore Emerald”, 1961).
[−] ck2 41d ago
Before Youtube and Wikipedia there used to be a great website I liked to read about Philo Farnsworth but cannot remember the name of it for the life of me now