Show HN: Cerno – CAPTCHA that targets LLM reasoning, not human biology (cerno.sh)

by plawlost 21 comments 12 points
Read article View on HN

21 comments

[−] iwalton3 45d ago
Unfortunately it didn't work for me with my trackball mouse. I tried multiple times. This is very likely also problematic for accessibility without another verification pathway, as assistive devices and screen readers would fail the heuristics too.
[−] modinfo 45d ago
It doesn't work for me either, I was trying multiple times and always fails, I was started to think, that maybe I'm the robot.
[−] opem 45d ago
this game is a rage bait! Try solving on a mobile device. I don't think an elderly person would ever be able to get through this!
[−] king_phil 45d ago
Was impossible for me to solve, too, on mobile.
[−] bestouff 45d ago
Same. I think an AI would have an easier time than me.
[−] ahofmann 45d ago
I managed once to complete the maze, but then it went into "checking" and a spinner forever.
[−] ge96 45d ago
Even when I successfully draw a path from green to red, not touching anything it says "Sorry that's not quite right"
[−] krackers 45d ago
New "impossible game" just dropped
[−] dcliu 45d ago
Interesting idea but it didn't accept me the first 3-4 times I tried to draw the path on laptop trackpad - going slow led to it failing before I was finished, going fast led to messy paths that were rejected as well. Could something like this work for users with different levels of dexterity?
[−] kccqzy 45d ago
I am on a mobile device and I consistently find that my finger is not precise enough to draw a path; it kept complaining about path “not quite right” where my path just touched the wall a little bit. And when my finger literally obscures the screen while drawing, it essentially means I have to memorize an entire path before beginning.

This requires significant spatial thinking skills and short-term memory for a human and it is absolutely unfair for a human to expend that much cognitive power to access a website.

[−] simlevesque 45d ago
I did it correctly with a mouse and was rejected. Then I drew a straight line and was rejected. Then I closed the tab.
[−] 1attice 45d ago
Did not work for me (kept getting "something's not right") but I applaud the concept.

I worry a bit about accessibility but that is a problem all CAPTCHAs have

[−] happytoexplain 45d ago
Everybody is saying it's impossible on mobile/trackpads, but I couldn't do it with a mouse either :(
[−] CoUHKT57BSe 45d ago
I'm assuming this is an april fools joke... cause it just don't work at all as a CAPTCHA.
[−] ranger_danger 45d ago
The description doesn't make sense either... like "Color-word interference at maze decision points", but there are no colors (or words) at the decision points.
[−] _diyar 45d ago
I‘m as confused as the other commenters, especially since it‘s unusable on an iPad.
[−] ravenical 45d ago
Is the idea that if you /pass/, you're an AI?
[−] DHolzer 45d ago
like the idea, but i cant see what i'm doing when my finger coveres the screen
[−] rickydroll 44d ago
I was lucky to get through two or three bends, given the state of my arms and hands. Yet another way, tech says fuck you if you're disabled.
[−] ceayo 45d ago
am i a robot or is this just way too hard?
[−] Surac 45d ago
Does not work on a touchscreen. Can’t see maze under finger and smh it always kicks me in the middle of the drawing
[−] mercatop 45d ago
[dead]