AI Won't Replace You, but a Manager Using AI Will (yanivpreiss.com)

by PretzelFisch 10 comments 16 points
Read article View on HN

10 comments

[−] mathieuh 38d ago
The way I look at it is I just need to get through the next year or so. I also don't believe AI is going to replace everyone, but I do believe that a lot of "leaders" are going to make cuts. They all read the same blogs and listen to the same podcasts and once one makes a move they seem to tend to follow each other.

Maybe it's wishful thinking on my part but I still don't see AI replacing absolutely everyone. As someone who I'd say tends to be in the upper 20% of performers but not setting the world on fire I'm not too worried about my job completely disappearing but I am worried in the short term about layoffs and chaos when loads of people are trying to find jobs at the same time.

[−] bearfox 38d ago
What happens after the next year then? Or if only top 10-5% performers stay (and that's in combo with AI).
[−] throwtillitstix 38d ago
Yes, my previous employer listens to these podcasts. After some random minor disagreement he fired me on a whim, and is now happily adding LLM-generated pasta to his spaghetti clusterf*ck on a daily basis. Throughput baby!
[−] kubb 38d ago
Or a manager will not be needed anymore with no reports to manage.
[−] throwaw12 38d ago
Everytime I hear that AI will replace someone I want to ask a question:

Okay, if AI can replace engineer with their Manager, what is stopping replacing manager with their managers and so on until CTO? or if we go with a different direction, AI replacing engineers with PMs, but then PM can be replaced by Solution Architects or Sales people, go even further customer can just create a meeting with AI agent, explain their needs and you don't need PM/SA/Engineers

Lets go even further instead of someone in the company explaining to AI, what if AI explains to another AI their company needs?

[−] josefritzishere 38d ago
Honestly, it's easier to replace a manager than an individual contribuitor. Most of a managers output is in reporting, approvals and decision making. These do require a lot of knowledge, and I don't think AI would be great at it but think of the cost savings.
[−] danielszlaski 38d ago
[dead]