A whole civilization might die tonight (nbcnews.com)

by hedayet 95 comments 146 points
Read article View on HN

95 comments

[−] jghn 38d ago
In a lot of ways I feel the discourse that he means a nuclear attack buries the lede. This is not likely to happen.

What is more likely to happen is just as bad. Devastating civil infrastructure would put 10s of millions of lives at risk.

And even if one were to look at this from a myopic USA centric lens, has anyone considered how many of these people we were told needed liberation are now radicalized against us?

[−] davidguetta 37d ago
What consequence would he suffer if he attack nuclearly vs everything it's done so far ?

the marginal cost for him is unfortunately not that high at this point

[−] CommanderData 38d ago
[flagged]
[−] Animats 38d ago
Response from Iran: "Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) says it will respond outside the region and deprive the United States and its allies of oil and gas “for many years” if the US crosses “red lines” and attacks civilian facilities."[1]

"Iran has closed all diplomatic and indirect channels of communication with the United States, the state-run Tehran Times reported ..." US media does not seem to have picked up on this, but media in India and China have.[2] But the common source seems to be "Tehran Times", and it's unclear who runs that or where they get their info. New York Times, AP, and AlJazeera are not saying that. Xinhua has a one-line note with no source. The US White House says Vance is talking to somebody. Politico says Vance is on "standby".[3]

A negotiated cease-fire seems unlikely now.

[1] https://www.aljazeera.com/news/liveblog/2026/4/7/iran-war-li...

[2] https://www.the-independent.com/bulletin/news/iran-mediators...

[3] https://www.politico.com/news/2026/04/06/vance-is-on-standby...

[−] nailer 38d ago
[flagged]
[−] comrade1234 38d ago
The markets dropped. He and his cronies are buying up stocks. Tomorrow he'll say Iran is negotiating and offering something amazing. The stocks will go up and they'll sell. Iran will say they have no idea what he's talking about. Wash and repeat.
[−] twen_ty 38d ago
This is what happens when there's no effective opposition. Where are the dems? Where's the press?
[−] baal80spam 38d ago
Why is the post miquoted?

It says: "A whole civilization will die tonight, never to be brought back again."

Will. Not might.

[−] nailer 38d ago

> A man stands at his home near a synagogue, which was damaged in a strike, in Tehran on Tuesday

Bizarre wording from this website. 90% of Jews in Iran left after the Islamic fundamentalists took over.

[−] Mr_Eri_Atlov 38d ago
The world will be engulfed in nuclear hellfire, and Hacker News mods will be flagging final sign-off posts as too political.
[−] spwa4 38d ago
How is Trump's threat the most extreme in this war? Hell, "a whole civilization might die tonight?". The islamic regime in Iran has explicitly set wiping out Persian civilization as it's goal, more than 50 years ago. And they've worked hard at it. Or how about:

Iran's regime threatens to make life in the middle east essentially impossible:

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/mar/23/iran-threat-to...

Iran's regime threatens to kill every Iranian they can "before giving Iran back to Iranians":

https://www.politico.com/news/2026/01/16/no-sign-of-new-prot...

[−] w10-1 38d ago
Destruction for no good reason.

Even those who don't care about innocent lives recognize the horrible consequences for everyone else:

- Iran empowered to tax the strait of Hormuz indefinitely with high insurance

- Russia empowered with access to the middle east since the Iranians will have to embrace their only ally

Trump enablers are responsible.

[−] elzbardico 38d ago
The world got so used to Don's deranged bravado, that I doubt that either china or russia have raised their DEFCON status equivalents, as they would probably do, should any other serious american president said the same thing.

Fucking clown.

[−] araes 38d ago
That went quickly from "America the supposed liberator is here" to "America is going to genocide your entire civilization."
[−] jacquesm 38d ago
Another thread that got 'buried':

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47674286

[−] iwontberude 38d ago
I take this seriously and it's made me sick. I can't get any work done when my stomach feels like its doing flips.
[−] LinuxAmbulance 38d ago
Yeah, good luck with that.

I'm sure he'll follow up with bailing the ocean.

[−] jfrororkforor 38d ago
Yet another genocidal threat. Now Iran needs nukes. Congratulation on amazing diplomacy!
[−] elzbardico 38d ago
[flagged]
[−] hedayet 38d ago
[flagged]
[−] zulux 38d ago
[flagged]